ESPN’s flagship shoutfest, First Take, has long and rightly been reviled for degrading everyone and everything it touches. Until co-host Skip Bayless departed earlier this year, that didn’t seem to matter at all to its loyal core audience, which happily tuned in each day no matter how repulsive or just plain stupid the proceedings were. Compared to same point last year, though, its ratings are down six percent (ESPN contends that it’s actually only four percent), and that actually masks how bad things are. Until June 21—Bayless’s final day on the program—ratings were actually up six percent compared to the same period in 2015. Since his departure, the show’s ratings are down a whopping 26 percent. Meanwhile, Second Take, the First Take, has drawn a respectable average of 90,000 viewers since its debut last month. It still trails far behind First Take—which has averaged 312,000 viewers in the same timespan—but is also way up on what FS1 aired in the same time slot last year, when a combination of mostly reruns and Fox Sports Live averaged 20,000 viewers. On its face, Bayless’s move look like a clear win for FS1 and a clear loss for ESPN. Under closer scrutiny, both networks look like losers for bothering to play this game at all. How do the shows stack up? When discussing First Take and Second Take and their effects on one another, teasing out cause from effect and making accurate comparisons is almost as much art as science, as it often is in television. Should a show’s ratings be compared to the same time period in 2015, or to all of 2015, or to some other time period in 2016? What effect does the flow of the sports calendar, or the steep drop in NFL ratings, have on viewership? What can be attributed to Bayless leaving First Take, and what can be attributed to direct competition from Second Take? Further complicating things is that all of the ratings data come from Nielsen—compiled by the wonderful site Sports TV Ratings—and some, by their nature, are fairly imprecise. Since each Nielsen panelist represents about 3,000 viewers, on any given day just a few panelists choosing whether or not to watch a show can in some cases significantly impact ratings. (Consider that while by FS1 standards Second Take is successful because its audience size is nearing six figures, as Sports TV Ratings explains, “viewership of around 100,000 or lower is technically what Nielsen refers to as a ‘scratch’ i.e., not enough Nielsen panelists watched for Nielsen to validate it.”) All of that being said, there is no way to positively spin the trajectory of First Take. Since Bayless left, the show has only had 400,000 viewers five times; before he left, the show was averaging over 400,000 viewers in 2016. The most sympathetic possible explanation is one Sports TV Ratings advances, which is that even without Bayless leaving, First Take would’ve suffered a significant ratings decline because of current trends in sports TV viewership. But they estimate that the decline would be 5–10 percent. As soon as Bayless left, the show’s ratings dropped 24 percent from to the same time period in 2015; since Second Take started, that number is down 28 percent. It is clear that Bayless’s departure from First Take caused a significant number of viewers to stop watching. Things are going much better for FS1. While Second Take isn’t a hit in an absolute sense—and FS1 won’t tell me whether it is meeting or exceeding expectations—its ratings are good relative to the rest of the network. They’re certainly much better than those Jason Whitlock’s and Colin Cowherd’s even with the NFL back, especially considering that the morning is a more challenging time slot than the evening. At a boring-sounding sports media conference earlier this week, Fox Sports National Networks president Jamie Horowitz explained the three areas where Second Take was helping the network: Horowitz said Skip Bayless’ move from ESPN to Fox has elevated ratings for the morning time slot that Bayless’ “[Second Take]” show occupies and had boosted the lead-in for “The Herd.” It also has cut into ratings for ESPN2’s “First Take.” Horowitz: “One guy has had an impact on three different shows on two networks. It’s been incredible.” This is worth parsing. Second Take draws 90,000 viewers, but not all of them are rabid Bayless fans who followed him over from ESPN. Before he showed up, nearly 20,000 people were reliably tuning in to FS1 in that time slot, which was consistently FS1's lowest rated where they almost always played reruns. Head-to-head with Second Take, First Take is down 130,000 viewers compared to the same time last year. This means that when the partnership of Bayless and co-host Stephen A. Smith broke up, roughly half those viewers—at most—followed Bayless to FS1, while the other half just stopped watching altogether. This means a few things. One is that Skip Bayless is a bigger draw than I’ve given him credit for. Deadspin’s general position is that pretty much no one tunes in to sports programming to watch specific announcers and studio hosts, and that ESPN is such a behemoth that they could broadcast two schmucks thumb-wrestling and a couple hundred thousand people would watch. But Skip Bayless’s exit seems to have caused First Take to lose a quarter of its viewership, and convinced an NFL stadium’s worth of people to flip over to a channel they rarely watch otherwise. It also, though, portends major trouble for FS1's now three-years-old quest to overtake ESPN. Bayless was ESPN’s biggest star, whom they were desperate to hold onto, and his defection represented a major coup for FS1. Yet half of the people who stopped watching First Take when he left didn’t bother to follow him to FS1, and even with a very solid debut, Second Take still draws less than 30 percent of a relatively poorly performing First Take. If making Skip Bayless one of the highest-paid people in sports media is what it costs to simply stop getting dunked on by ESPN, and even that isn’t enough to come close to competing, what chance does FS1 possibly have? I asked Fox Sports how they feel Second Take is doing, and for any ratings data they wanted to show me. Their comments echoed Horowitz’s above, and their data were basically the same as mine. They emphasized how well Second Take is doing compared to the same time slot last year, but a 358 percent increase on almost nothing still isn’t very much. They also had numbers showing that the audience is trending younger and wealthier with Bayless in the fold, and that Second Take has served to raise the ratings of the show that follows, The Herd. This last point may be the one most worth considering here. The Herd, a simulcast of Colin Cowherd’s radio show, runs on FS1 most days from 12:00 to 3:00 p.m. Eastern. In the month before Second Take debuted, it averaged 52,000 viewers. Since then, it has averaged 91,000. Think about that for a second. To make Second Take happen, Fox Sports is paying Skip Bayless $6.5 million annually and co-host Shannon Sharpe doubtless makes a lot, too. They hired who knows how many producers and PAs, built a brand new set, and paid for promotional billboards in Bristol. Beyond that, they’ve paid a tangible cost in terms of their reputation; some Fox Sports employees are embarrassed to work at the same network as Bayless, and the move has solidified the network’s image as the home of ESPN castoffs and the sports alt-right, the place where hacks go to die. What all of this investment has bought FS1 is an audience nearly large enough to be semi-reliably measured, and the best proof they can offer that the strategy is working for the network overall is that the audience doesn’t turn the channel when a simulcast of a braying donkey’s radio show comes on. For all the money and attention that has been lavished upon Second Take, slightly more people are watching a damn simulcast of a radio show. Why bother playing this game at all? For all the words written here, and all the time the ESPN and FS1 research and communications staffs put into giving out information that presents their networks in the best possible light, and all the huge salaries paid to some of the people named above, the hard-to-avoid point is that none of this matters. The overwhelming belief of the vast majority of sports-media decision makers is that people subscribe to and watch sports networks based upon the live sports they offer at night, and the ratings of those programs dwarf any of the changes discussed above. A while back, I asked a high-ranking sports media executive at a major rights-holding network whether daytime opinion programming matters. This is how the executive responded: Any of the studio shows, it is 100 percent around the game. And to me, to drive meaningful cable rates, it is probably the top three to five leagues, sports. Once you get beyond that, you’re not driving enough. If you were an independent company and not tied to massive companies … maybe you’d be okay with the type of outlook you could get from [daytime opinion shows], but it is so meaningless in these massive companies. The live sports that drive cable ratings draw, at worst, an order of magnitude more than Second Take, and many times that for the most popular sports. A loss of 130,000 viewers, a huge drop for First Take, is a rounding error for Monday Night Football, NBA on ESPN, and most other programming ESPN runs in the evening. Skip Bayless’s departure has been catastrophic for First Take and yet hasn’t mattered in the least to ESPN, or, really, to FS1, a major cable network with a flagship show watched by as many people as read a run-of-the-mill post on Deadspin. Which leaves us with a question: If there are no stakes in this game, why, exactly, is anyone playing?
Related Posts
Josef Hickersberger announced his retirement as Austrian coach in an interview to be published on Tuesday which will appear on the day that the Austrian federation were to decide on his future.
The 60-year-old tells daily newspaper Der Standard that he feels exhausted after coaching co-hosts Austria at Euro 2008 where they bowed out in the first round with just one point and having scored one goal.
I am stopping I feel empty and tired, I need to take a break and recharge the batteries, said Hickersberger, who was in his second spell as coach after leading them to the 1990 World Cup finals but resigning later that year after a Euro 92 qualifier defeat by the Faroe Islands.
The chapter is closed. My mission has been accomplished. I have reflected long and hard.…
Oliver Bierhoff, whose golden goal won Euro 96, says Germany must approach Sunday s Euro 2008 final against Spain without fear as the Germans bid to win a fourth European title.
The 40-year-old Germany manager scored the winner in extra-time against the Czech Republic at Wembley in 1996 and the ex-AC Milan striker expects the Germans to attack Luis Aragones s Spain in Vienna.
Defender Philipp Lahm put Germany in the final with a 90th-minute winner to see off Turkey 3-2 in Basel s semi-final on Wednesday, but his side had to come from behind after a lack-lustre first half.
Only in their 3-2 quarter-final win over Portugal have Germany impressed and Bierhoff expects his side must be less tense in the final than in their shock group stage defeat to Croatia or th…
Los Angeles FC momentarily opened up a four-point gap atop the Western Conference in the MLS, defeating Sporting KC 2-0 on Saturday.
Gareth Bale came off the bench to score his first goal in the MLS and seal the three points for LAFC, after Cristian Arango s well-taken opener.
With Giorgio Chiellini also starting, Steve Cherundolo s side absorbed pressure after Arango scored in the 56th minute, firing past Tim Melia at his near post with a confident finish on the run.
Bale was able to settle the result in transition for LAFC in the 83rd minute, driving low into the corner after creating separation from Nicolas Isimat-Mirin.
The win puts LAFC four points ahead of second-placed Austin FC in the West, who are still to face New York RB on Sunday, while Nashv…
Luiz Felipe Scolari has warned Chelsea s rivals that he won t pull any punches in the Premier League title fight.
Scolari has never been afraid to deliver a knockout blow on or off the pitch and the Brazilian was quick to emphasise his street-fighting credentials as he set his sights on English football s heavy-weights.
The 59-year-old is a shrewd operator who knows exactly what buttons to push to get the best out of his players. But he also has a fiery temperament that occasionally flares in spectacular fashion.
Scolari s most famous eruption came during his time as Portugal coach when he punched Serbia s Ivica Dragutinovic following a touchline clash in a Euro 2008 qualifier.
As a newcomer in the Premier League, Scolari could have opted to keep a l…
Lyon president Jean-Michel Aulas would prefer to sell Tanguy Ndombele to Juventus rather than Manchester United, Manchester City or Paris Saint-Germain.
Powerful midfielder Ndombele has been in impressive form for the Ligue 1 side this season, making 45 appearances across all competitions and scoring two goals in the Champions League.
His displays are reported to have drawn interest from a number of Europe s biggest clubs, with Aulas confirming Juve, PSG and the two Manchester giants have all declared a liking for the 22-year-old.
And Aulas believes a move to Serie A champions Juve where Ndombele could play alongside former Lyon playmaker Miralem Pjanic would suit the France international.
It s true that Juve are after Ndombele, he told Tuttosport.
…
Lionel Messi, Luis Suarez and Paulinho were on target as Barcelona cruised to a 3-0 home win against Levante on Sunday which saw LaLiga s leaders stretch their advantage over Atletico Madrid back to nine points.
Barcelona ended 2017 with a crushing Clasico win at Real Madrid who are now 17 points off the pace, albeit with two games in hand and they continued the club-record start to a season with ease, although there was no sign of Philippe Coutinho.
A deal worth a reported £142million was announced by Barca on Saturday, but Ernesto Valverde s men had more than enough to beat Levante prior to the Brazil international s formal arrival at Camp Nou.
Coutinho s predecessor as Barca s record signing, Ousmane Dembele, made his first start since September after recover…
Real Madrid defender Raphael Varane insists he is fully focused on the FIFA World Cup amid interest from Premier League club Chelsea.
The French central defender is being tipped to reunite with former Real manager Jose Mourinho at Chelsea after David Luiz agreed to depart Stamford Bridge for Ligue 1 champions Paris Saint-Germain.
Varane was an ever-present during Mourinho s final season in charge of the Madrid club, who eventually finished second behind Barcelona in 2012-13.
But the 21-year-old is not thinking about his club future as Didier Deschamps France prepare to face Switzerland, Ecuador and Honduras in Group E at the World Cup in Brazil.
Right now, I m not thinking about (the interest from Chelsea), we have the World Cup ahead of us, Varane told French fo…
Verona are willing to sell Juan Manuel Iturbe, but only if they receive the right offer for the Argentine forward.
Iturbe enjoyed a fine season with the Serie A side last season, scoring eight goals as Verona comfortably avoided a return to Serie B following promotion in 2012-13.
The 21-year-old initially joined on loan from Porto, but his move to the Italian outfit was made permanent in May when Verona parted with €15million to secure his services.
Real Madrid, Barcelona, Liverpool and Arsenal have all been credited with an interest in Iturbe.
However, Verona sporting director Sean Sogliano is adamant that a fair price will be need to paid in order for them to part with their star player.
Even though all the focus is on him, he is calm and aware that he …
Juventus legend Giampiero Boniperti, the club s honorary president, has died aged 92.
The Bianconeri announced his passing on Friday.
Boniperti represented Juve for 15 years as a player, winning five Scudetti between 1946 and 1961.
He retired having scored 179 goals for the Turin club, a record that stood for almost 40 years before it was passed by Alessandro Del Piero.
Boniperti s 443 Serie A appearances also set a Juve benchmark, again topped by Del Piero.
The club great became Juve president in 1971, overseeing 16 trophy wins, and was later given his honorary title.
Winning is not important, but it is the only thing that matters, he was famously quoted.
Se un bambino mi chiedesse chi è Gianpiero Boniperti risponderei che sempl…
Erling Haaland is undergoing his rehabilitation from a hamstring injury in Qatar, Borussia Dortmund s sporting director Michael Zorc has confirmed.
Haaland was left out of Dortmund s squad for their Champions League encounter with Lazio on December 2, with the club subsequently revealing the Norway sensation had suffered a hamstring injury in training.
His absence was felt as Dortmund were held to 1-1 draws by both Lazio and Eintracht Frankfurt, though Lucien Favre s side did then beat Zenit to finish top of their Champions League group.
Favre put Haaland s injury down to an accumulation of games, with the 20-year-old having featured 14 times for Dortmund prior to his injury.
Zorc has now confirmed the striker is recovering in Qatar after requesting pe…